I'm Ok- You're Ok by Thomas A. Harris | Chapter 1
Harris structures the chapter around three key figures to build the foundation:
- Freud — Shows the problem (complex, hard-to-understand theories about the unconscious, Id/Ego/Superego).
- Penfield — Provides the scientific/biological evidence (the brain records experiences in detail, including emotions from childhood).
- Berne — Supplies the practical solution: a simple, usable model that bridges the gap.
Berne is a psychiatrist that introduced the idea:
Transactional Analysis
Definition
Definition
Transactional analysis is defined as "the unit of social interaction"
- - -
Thankfully I had AI revise this because I would have missed framing it this way, which after reading Chapter 1, I find is a crucial bit for the rest. My summary of the chapter is simply.
Therapists have noticed that their patients have visible shifts in their behaviors during sessions. The shifts can be described as a child-like and a parent-like version in the same person.
Berne developed Transactional Analysis, a system for understanding the way we interact with one another. His model consists of 2 states in a person, Child, Parent, and Adult.
Harris takes Berne’s model and references the work of neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield. In Penfield’s studies, electrical stimulation of the temporal cortex caused patients to experience a vivid “replay” of past events. Notably, these replays were not like silent films — they included senses (smell, sound) and emotions. Penfield saw the brain as functioning like a high-fidelity recorder, or at least that is how Harris presents the research.
If you can imagine, we can be living in 2 states at the same time. Simultaneously be aware of being on the operating table while reliving something from the past (reference to the study).
Since the book was written in 1967, I checked if our understanding of memory has developed past this information. We now know that recall is reconstructive and less reliable than a "perfect recording". However, the important point for this topic is not perfect recall, but that early experiences are recorded and stored in the brain — and they carry on with us throughout our lives.
Therapists have noticed that their patients have visible shifts in their behaviors during sessions. The shifts can be described as a child-like and a parent-like version in the same person.
Berne developed Transactional Analysis, a system for understanding the way we interact with one another. His model consists of 2 states in a person, Child, Parent, and Adult.
Harris takes Berne’s model and references the work of neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield. In Penfield’s studies, electrical stimulation of the temporal cortex caused patients to experience a vivid “replay” of past events. Notably, these replays were not like silent films — they included senses (smell, sound) and emotions. Penfield saw the brain as functioning like a high-fidelity recorder, or at least that is how Harris presents the research.
If you can imagine, we can be living in 2 states at the same time. Simultaneously be aware of being on the operating table while reliving something from the past (reference to the study).
Since the book was written in 1967, I checked if our understanding of memory has developed past this information. We now know that recall is reconstructive and less reliable than a "perfect recording". However, the important point for this topic is not perfect recall, but that early experiences are recorded and stored in the brain — and they carry on with us throughout our lives.
Comments
Post a Comment